On Fairness and Equality
In the United States, there’s been a huge emphasis on this issue of fairness and equality. There’s has been a long history of prejudice and hatred born from the differences between people. American slavery (note the distinction) was borne out of the idea that the other, the people of color, were not equal to those who were. All of this stuff with affirmative action and black history month and anti-discrimination have been spawned as a result, and slow but surely the culture and mindset is changing. This is good, without a doubt, but is it really addressing the real issue? Is this really what the solution looks like? It’s been a century and a half since slaver was abolished. It’s been 50 years since the African American Civil Rights movement succeeded. But even still, racism and prejudice still exist. Why?
I contend that it is because fairness and equality is a myth. At least, in the human estimation. Humans are inherently born unequal. But that is different, very different, from saying one person is superior to another. Just because two things are different does not mean that they can be compared. Can the hand say to the foot that it is superior? Can the brain say to the big toe that is superior? Clearly not, for they are different. Sure, one may be more stronger or more central or more useful, but they are all important nonetheless.
Imagine two children fighting over a toy. One comes up to you and says, “It’s not fair, he’s been playing with it so much more than I have! It should be my turn! It’s not fair!” You never see the opposite. You wouldn’t see a child coming up to you and saying, “It’s not fair! I’ve been playing with this toy too much! I should give it to my friend who hasn’t been able to play with it as much as I have.” In the same way, when we say we want equality, or we want fairness, I doubt that most people actually desire that. It is instead engendered in sin, in envy and in pride.
Therefore, as a Christian I do not believe in fairness. I do not believe in equality. I will go so far to say that I am meant to be unfair, to treat people unequally.
Inherently, people are different. God has made people differently. Therefore we should treat them differently. There is no “one size fits all.” Why are we trying to reduce humanity to a colorless, genderless, distinctiveless mass?
Not only that, but if we look at God, the Christian God, is He fair? Does He treat everyone equally? No, He doesn’t. And how marvelous and wonderful it is, that He does not treat everyone equally or fairly. For if He were fair, then we would be dead in our sins. At our hands, Jesus suffered the ultimate unfair punishment: that He, who was without blemish, died for the sake of humanity. For if He treated us all equally, then we would all be the same. We would not have the vibrance of life that comes from diversity, that comes from being male or female, from being white or black or somewhere in between, and everything else besides. And in that, if He treated us all the same, then He could not love us perfectly the way we are.
Therefore, as a Christian, I do not feel this need to abolish inequality. The wealth gap will always exist. The gender divide will always exist. Diversity will always exist. I do not need to treat all people the same, because they are not all the same. Rather, I seek to interact and love people despite our differences, despite our disparities.
Therefore, as a Christian, I seek to be unfair. I seek to put others before myself. To love them even if I do not think that they are deserving of love. To suffer transgressions at the hands of others, and to turn the other cheek. To show grace and mercy, instead of demanding fairness.
The issue that people have is not about fairness or equality. It is the fact that many injustices and sin occur in the name of inequality and unfairness. And because of that, we run to a concept of fairness and equality, to arbitrated rules and regulations, creating a falsehood that seems to, in theory, solve the problems. However, it is merely replacing a lie with another lie.
It has, and always will be, an issue of the heart. And I continue to struggle with this. Not to love people “because,” but to love people “despite.”
Edit: See the addendum. I am not advocating that we stop fighting for human rights or things like that. What I am trying to say is that we do not fight for these things because “it is not equal or not fair,” but rather that the reason we fight against prejudice is because they breed hatred and sin. A difference in wealth is bad, for example, only if the wealth is being misused. The latter half I did not really address, so my bad.